One that was not on the list was Bonne Bell Liquid Lip Smackers. Yes, I know I'm 26. And I know lip smackers are geared towards young teen and pre-teen girls, even girls in grade school. But I just can't let them go. I have tried a million lip glosses over the years, and Bonne Bell just gets it. The formula is dead on, it makes my lips look and feel amazing. I recently tried the Skittles flavored liquid lip smackers and loved it. It was a bit sticky and didn't have as much glide as the smackers roll on shiner. But it's a good runner up. I bought a pack of 5 from my local Target for $9.29. They have them in abundance, so I don't have to worry about ordering online or not being able to find them.
Another gloss I'm fond of is Cover Girl Wet Slicks (clear). You can find them at any local drug store. I got mine from CVS for $6.99, I also like CG Wet Slicks Fruit Spritzers. My cousin gave me a raspberry flavored one and I fell in love with it. They can also be purchased at your local drug store.
So the rulings go as follows:
Neutrogena Moisture Shine Lip Soother Cooler Hydragel - 3 stars
Urban Decay Honey Infused Lip Therapy - 4.5 stars
Aquafina Hydrating Lip Oil - 2.5 stars
Dasani Roll On Lip Gloss - 2.5 stars
Sephora Super Nourishing Lip Balm - 1 star
Pacifica Coconut Pearls Luminizing Lip Quench - - 4 stars
Liquid Lip Smackers - 4.5 stars
Cover Girl Wet Slicks - 4.5 stars